How to Avoid Common Pitfalls in Mentoring
So, you’ve started one-on-one mentoring sessions with your kids—fantastic! You’re investing in their growth, strengthening your relationship, and creating a powerful family tradition. But as with anything worthwhile, there are some common mistakes that can creep in and derail your efforts.
Let’s talk about the most frequent mentoring pitfalls and how to sidestep them to keep your sessions meaningful and effective.
1. Turning It Into a Lecture
🚨 The Pitfall: You find yourself doing most of the talking, offering advice, and correcting their mistakes rather than listening.
✅ The Fix: Remember, mentoring is a conversation, not a lecture. Let your child do the majority of the talking. Ask open-ended questions and listen without immediately jumping in with solutions. This is their space to process, reflect, and grow.
2. Being Too Rigid with the Structure
🚨 The Pitfall: You stick to the mentoring sheet like it’s a legal contract, moving from question to question without flexibility.
✅ The Fix: The structure is there to guide, not control, the conversation. If your child is opening up about something important, don’t cut them off to move to the next section. Be present and follow where the discussion naturally leads.
3. Not Following Up on Goals
🚨 The Pitfall: You set great goals together, but the next week, there’s no real follow-up. Your child forgets, and you don’t check in.
✅ The Fix: Keep their goals visible! Write them somewhere they can see them daily. During the next session, celebrate progress—even small steps. Consistent follow-up shows that these goals matter.
4. Overloading with Too Many Goals
🚨 The Pitfall: Your child walks away with a long to-do list, feeling overwhelmed rather than empowered.
✅ The Fix: Stick to three focused goals—Spiritual, Physical, and Educational (or Skill Learning in the summer). This keeps things manageable and helps them experience success without burnout.
5. Skipping the Fun and Connection
🚨 The Pitfall: The session starts feeling like a business meeting rather than a special one-on-one moment.
✅ The Fix: Keep it lighthearted! Start with exciting news, talk about fun plans, and wrap up by discussing how they plan to enjoy the week. Joy is just as important as growth.
6. Being Inconsistent
🚨 The Pitfall: Sessions get skipped due to busyness, and eventually, they fade out entirely.
✅ The Fix: Treat mentoring sessions as non-negotiable appointments. If something urgent comes up, reschedule—but don’t cancel. Consistency builds trust and reinforces their importance.
7. Expecting Immediate Deep Conversations
🚨 The Pitfall: You want deep, meaningful discussions, but your child gives one-word answers or doesn’t seem engaged.
✅ The Fix: Be patient. Some kids take time to open up. Keep showing up, keep asking, and keep making it a positive experience. Over time, they’ll start to share more naturally.
Final Thoughts
Mentoring isn’t about perfection—it’s about presence. If you find yourself falling into any of these pitfalls, don’t be discouraged. Simply adjust, refocus, and keep moving forward. The goal is connection, growth, and trust, and every session strengthens that foundation.
Want a structured way to keep your mentoring sessions on track? Download our Mentoring Session Sheets to guide your conversations each week.
Download the Mentoring Sheets Here!
Related Posts on Self-Government & Parenting
➡ A Self-Government Approach to Restoring Peace & Order in Your Home
➡ The Power of Calm Leadership
➡ What to do When Kids Test Boundaries.
Stay tuned for our next post: Mentoring for Different Ages—How to Adapt for Toddlers, Teens, and Beyond!